On April 31, the U.S. Attorney General's office re-indicted San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and two workers on charges that their 2000 pipe insulation removal violated Clean Air Act rules by exposing residents to potentially cancer-causing asbestos.
On August 31, four months into the new trial, U.S. Federal Judge Dana Sabraw - who threw out a previous conviction - ruled that prosecutors can't use key evidence acquired between 2000 and 2007 to further their contention that SDG&E and two workers acted in an unsafe manner during a 2000 excavation in Lemon Grove, a California city located about 17 miles north of the Mexican border.
Judge Sabraw's recent decision also engendered a postponement of the current trial, until October 9, as prosecutors decide how to proceed now that the essential portion of their evidence has been ruled inadmissible.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Melanie Pierson had no comment on the ruling, as did attorneys for SDG&E. Kyle Rheubottom, one of two workers also facing charges, said he was pleased with the ruling, and his attorney, Michael Lipman, added that he felt the judge had made precisely the right decision.
The case began in 1997, when SDG&E found a buyer for its Encanto Gas Holder facility in Lemon Grove. This necessitated an asbestos survey, which was delivered in January of 1998, revealing the presence of regulated, asbestos-containing material on coatings applied to underground piping.
In June of 2000, SDG&E began soliciting bids from contractors for removal of piping. It also started the process itself, removing more than 40,000 feet of pipe wrapping without any of the paperwork required by state and federal agencies which regulate asbestos handling, removal and disposal. The move was presumably an effort to save time and/or money.
The removal came to the attention of officials in San Diego County and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency after Lemon Grove residents engaged in a whistleblower campaign against the utility's removal efforts. San Diego County filed a civil suit against the utility, and a federal indictment in January of 2006 instigated a lawsuit.
The case was based on 27 asbestos-containing samples from the 16-acre site where SDG&E, through its Encanto facility, maintained almost 10 miles of underground gas pipeline. At the time of the conviction, Granta Nakayama, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's assistant administrator for Enforcement and Compliance Assurance, noted that the conviction sent a clear message from the federal government that financial gain would not be allowed to come before any obligation to obey the law.
In the initial case, the jury found SDG&E, Rhuebottom (an employee working for SDG&E site contractor, IT Corporation) and David Williamson, SDG&E environmental specialist, all in violation of Clean Air Act standards. Each was convicted on one count for: failing to give adequate notice in advance of the asbestos removal, for failing to properly wet the asbestos during removal, for leaving the Encanto facility without properly insuring that the asbestos-containing material was put in a leak-proof container, and for falsely stating that an SDG&E employee was a certified asbestos consultant.
The conviction came down in July of 2007. A third worker, SDG&E employee Jacquelyn McHugh, was acquitted. The conviction resulted in fines, to SDG&E, of up to $2 million, and each of the workers faced up to five years in prison and $250,000 in fines.
Those convictions were dismissed by Federal Judge Sabraw, who said prosecutors used the wrong testing method to determine the amounts and quality of the asbestos found in the pipe insulations. Those tests, which showed asbestos levels between 37 percent and 42 percent, were later called into question by further tests that showed only 1.55 to 3.66 percent, and a final test by defense experts which showed asbestos levels below one percent, which is well under the 1989 EPA mandate.
This is the evidence that Judge Sabraw is now refusing to have admitted, a move that effectively kills the prosecution's case and makes Rheubottom's change of plea offering moot. According to Lipman, the prosecution will now have to decide whether to appeal the ruling or drop the case entirely.
Asbestos, a fibrous mineral widely used in insulating materials during most of the last century, can - when inhaled or ingested - cause mesothelioma, a particularly lethal cancer of the mesothelial lining of the lungs and abdomen. Occurring as either pleural mesothelioma (lungs), peritoneal mesothelioma (abdomen), or pericardial mesothelioma (heart), though most commonly as the pleural form, the cancer commonly lies dormant for decades before producing symptoms definitive enough to permit diagnosis. By then, the prognosis is generally poor, with most victims given between a year and 18 months to live.
In October of 2008, the Lemon Grove City Council approved the former asbestos site for use as a 78-home complex called Citrus Heights. The only stipulation is that the developer, Carter Reese and Associates, will fund monitoring during construction, via an independent asbestos remediation contractor, to determine the presence of asbestos, especially airborne asbestos. Construction has yet to begin.
Friday, December 18, 2009
Volunteer Students Reduce Mesothelioma Risk by Cleaning Up Historic Train Station
It was great summer activity, and served a worthy purpose, but to the teens hired by Grosse Pointe billionaire Manuel "Matty" Maroun to clean up the abandoned Michigan Central Train Station (MCTS) this past summer, it also means exposure to toxic, and possibly, lethal asbestos fibers found in the debris and released into the air via sweeping.
After the old Michigan Central Depot burned, on December 26, 1913, a still incomplete but architecturally stunning 17-story building off Michigan Avenue was put into service instead. It thrived before and during WWII, but the gradual rise of automobiles, and their increasing affordability, dampened passenger train service until, by 1956, the MCTS was put up for sale.
No buyers came forward, and it was again offered for sale in 1963, but again no one appeared interested. In 1967, the main entrance and park were closed. In 1971, Amtrak took over America's passenger train service, and more than a million dollars was invested into renovating the MCTS. But the passenger train boom never materialized and, in 1984, the building was sold for a transportation center that never occurred. On January 5, 1988, the last train left the MCTS.
Eventually, Maroun bought the building, which remained open throughout much of the 1990s, though much of the interior plaster and brass artwork was gutted by thieves. In 2004, city officials agreed to purchase it for a new Detroit Police headquarters. The deal fell through, and the city of Detroit has since been plagued with such overwhelming financial catastrophe (more recently, the bankruptcy of the auto industry) that the police are likely to continue in their old headquarters for the foreseeable future.
The MCTS cleanup began on June 30 with a handful of teens and employees from Maroun-owned Detroit International Bridge Company (which owns the Ambassador Bridge under a company of the same name). At the behest of organizer John Mohyi, the first phase of cleanup was intended to be a new beginning for the aging landmark under a grassroots campaign called Save Michigan Central, with owner Maroun providing all the equipment the group requested. Maroun even gave a BBQ for youth volunteers.
The project has since turned into a PR and health disaster. The teens, all from the volunteer Detroit organization Summer In The City, founded in 2002 and aimed at recruiting high school and college youth to build character, relationships and a sense of belonging, face the potential of asbestos contamination that may impact the rest of their young lives.
Asbestos, a fibrous mineral widely used in construction (as an insulator, in plaster, and in floor and ceiling tiles) well into the middle of the last century, is a toxic substance that, when disturbed or broken and inhaled or ingested, can lead to a number of illnesses, including mesothelioma, or cancer of the mesothelial lining of the chest and abdomen.
Mesothelioma occurs in several distinct types (pleural, in the lungs; peritoneal, in the abdomen; and pericardial, the heart). The most common is pleural, which normally lies dormant for up to 50 years, producing few definitive symptoms under the tumor is well advanced. By that time, the prognosis is very poor, with most patients given between a year and 18 months to live. Some ten percent may survive up to five years, but only where the cancer is caught early and treated aggressively by radical single or combination therapies.
Thomas Vincent, of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), noted that the DEQ was not able to take samples until the volunteers finished working, but that at least one sample, on duct work found in a dumpster, was positive for friable asbestos, the kind that can become airborne and present the greatest danger. Said material was clearly moved from inside to outside, according to Vincent.
The volunteers were not given respirators by Maroun, nor provided with protective clothing of any kind, and Dr. Michael Harbut, co-director of the National Center for Asbestos Cancer and a member of the Karmanos Cancer Institute, has called the lapse "absolutely dumb", adding that there is no safe level of asbestos exposure. This position is supported by the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Division (OSHA), the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC), and the American Cancer Society, who have previously noted that a day or a lifetime can trigger mesothelioma.
Detroit International Bridge Company President Dan Stamper has since argued that the company wasn't aware of the presence of asbestos, and did suspend all volunteer work once asbestos was discovered. However, the DEQ may impose fines and penalties once a full review is completed.
Dr. Harbut is recommending a profile of tests - including complete lung function testing, a physical, and a low-dose chest x-ray - to all volunteers, a protocol that should be followed up every five years for at least 15 years, with appropriate cancer surveillance for the rest of the volunteer's life. The tests are covered under most insurance plans. For those volunteers lacking medical insurance, Karmanos is offering entry into their CDC- and EPA-funded studies (and database) which offer blood tests for detecting lung cancer and mesothelioma early.
After the old Michigan Central Depot burned, on December 26, 1913, a still incomplete but architecturally stunning 17-story building off Michigan Avenue was put into service instead. It thrived before and during WWII, but the gradual rise of automobiles, and their increasing affordability, dampened passenger train service until, by 1956, the MCTS was put up for sale.
No buyers came forward, and it was again offered for sale in 1963, but again no one appeared interested. In 1967, the main entrance and park were closed. In 1971, Amtrak took over America's passenger train service, and more than a million dollars was invested into renovating the MCTS. But the passenger train boom never materialized and, in 1984, the building was sold for a transportation center that never occurred. On January 5, 1988, the last train left the MCTS.
Eventually, Maroun bought the building, which remained open throughout much of the 1990s, though much of the interior plaster and brass artwork was gutted by thieves. In 2004, city officials agreed to purchase it for a new Detroit Police headquarters. The deal fell through, and the city of Detroit has since been plagued with such overwhelming financial catastrophe (more recently, the bankruptcy of the auto industry) that the police are likely to continue in their old headquarters for the foreseeable future.
The MCTS cleanup began on June 30 with a handful of teens and employees from Maroun-owned Detroit International Bridge Company (which owns the Ambassador Bridge under a company of the same name). At the behest of organizer John Mohyi, the first phase of cleanup was intended to be a new beginning for the aging landmark under a grassroots campaign called Save Michigan Central, with owner Maroun providing all the equipment the group requested. Maroun even gave a BBQ for youth volunteers.
The project has since turned into a PR and health disaster. The teens, all from the volunteer Detroit organization Summer In The City, founded in 2002 and aimed at recruiting high school and college youth to build character, relationships and a sense of belonging, face the potential of asbestos contamination that may impact the rest of their young lives.
Asbestos, a fibrous mineral widely used in construction (as an insulator, in plaster, and in floor and ceiling tiles) well into the middle of the last century, is a toxic substance that, when disturbed or broken and inhaled or ingested, can lead to a number of illnesses, including mesothelioma, or cancer of the mesothelial lining of the chest and abdomen.
Mesothelioma occurs in several distinct types (pleural, in the lungs; peritoneal, in the abdomen; and pericardial, the heart). The most common is pleural, which normally lies dormant for up to 50 years, producing few definitive symptoms under the tumor is well advanced. By that time, the prognosis is very poor, with most patients given between a year and 18 months to live. Some ten percent may survive up to five years, but only where the cancer is caught early and treated aggressively by radical single or combination therapies.
Thomas Vincent, of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), noted that the DEQ was not able to take samples until the volunteers finished working, but that at least one sample, on duct work found in a dumpster, was positive for friable asbestos, the kind that can become airborne and present the greatest danger. Said material was clearly moved from inside to outside, according to Vincent.
The volunteers were not given respirators by Maroun, nor provided with protective clothing of any kind, and Dr. Michael Harbut, co-director of the National Center for Asbestos Cancer and a member of the Karmanos Cancer Institute, has called the lapse "absolutely dumb", adding that there is no safe level of asbestos exposure. This position is supported by the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Division (OSHA), the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC), and the American Cancer Society, who have previously noted that a day or a lifetime can trigger mesothelioma.
Detroit International Bridge Company President Dan Stamper has since argued that the company wasn't aware of the presence of asbestos, and did suspend all volunteer work once asbestos was discovered. However, the DEQ may impose fines and penalties once a full review is completed.
Dr. Harbut is recommending a profile of tests - including complete lung function testing, a physical, and a low-dose chest x-ray - to all volunteers, a protocol that should be followed up every five years for at least 15 years, with appropriate cancer surveillance for the rest of the volunteer's life. The tests are covered under most insurance plans. For those volunteers lacking medical insurance, Karmanos is offering entry into their CDC- and EPA-funded studies (and database) which offer blood tests for detecting lung cancer and mesothelioma early.
New York Declares September 26 Mesothelioma Awareness Day
New York Governor David Patterson has declared Saturday, September 26, Mesothelioma Awareness Day. Mesothelioma, a rare form of cancer caused by exposure to asbestos, affects between 2500 and 3000 Americans every year.
The first Mesothelioma Awareness Day was held in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 2003. With the amount of industrial pollutants generated by the area’s steel mills, coal mines and other plants and factories, and the attendant lung diseases that many of the workers in those facilities would later develop, a group approached the Pittsburgh City Council and requested that they recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day to help let other workers know about the dangerous disease and raise funds to finance treatments and clinical trials for patients. The group chose September 26 to commemorate the wedding anniversary of a patient who died from mesothelioma and his widow, who brought the cause to their attention.
In New Jersey, State Senator Tom Kean has proposed that his state recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day in an effort to make sure that lawmakers, cancer researchers and the general public remember patients who have contracted the disease. In Kentucky, the state House of Representatives issued a proclamation to recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day and to honor former state legislator Ron Cyrus, who died from the disease.
MesotheliomaWeb offers free top quality information about this form of cancer. Our website covers the causes of the disease, symptoms, diagnostic procedures, and types of treatment doctors employ. Further, our co-ordinators are available to answer individual questions from patients and their families and we can help find specialists and hospitals.
The first Mesothelioma Awareness Day was held in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 2003. With the amount of industrial pollutants generated by the area’s steel mills, coal mines and other plants and factories, and the attendant lung diseases that many of the workers in those facilities would later develop, a group approached the Pittsburgh City Council and requested that they recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day to help let other workers know about the dangerous disease and raise funds to finance treatments and clinical trials for patients. The group chose September 26 to commemorate the wedding anniversary of a patient who died from mesothelioma and his widow, who brought the cause to their attention.
In New Jersey, State Senator Tom Kean has proposed that his state recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day in an effort to make sure that lawmakers, cancer researchers and the general public remember patients who have contracted the disease. In Kentucky, the state House of Representatives issued a proclamation to recognize Mesothelioma Awareness Day and to honor former state legislator Ron Cyrus, who died from the disease.
MesotheliomaWeb offers free top quality information about this form of cancer. Our website covers the causes of the disease, symptoms, diagnostic procedures, and types of treatment doctors employ. Further, our co-ordinators are available to answer individual questions from patients and their families and we can help find specialists and hospitals.
New York State School Closes on Asbestos Discovery
In the small community of Schroon Lake, population about 1,800, located on the eastern edge of the Adirondack Park Preserve in the Adirondack Mountains, the students of the area’s single school found classes suspended Wednesday, September 23, when a building and renovation project uncovered asbestos behind a bathroom wall.
Officials at Schroon Lake Central School hope to bring the students back on Thursday. In the interim, The Essex County Health Department is standing by to make sure asbestos remediation in performed in accordance with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations, as well as the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) mandates.
The school, built in 1936 when former President Franklin D. Roosevelt instituted the Works Progress Administration (WPA) to support a flagging economy, is certainly old enough to contain asbestos, which was widely used in various construction materials like insulation, floor and ceiling tiles, sealants and mastics during most of the last century.
In 1989, when health officials began to recognize its dangers, the EPA limited the use of asbestos in domestic products to one percent or less by weight (or volume), thus greatly curtailing the legacy costs of asbestos illnesses, which are estimated by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) to total about $120 to $150 billion between 2005 and 2055.
Asbestos is comprised of long, very fine fibers which can, when inhaled or ingested, lead to a number of debilitating and potentially fatal diseases. The first of these is asbestosis, which is usually acquired through long exposure to asbestos. The other is mesothelioma, a cancer of the mesothelial lining inside the body that occurs as pleural mesothelioma (the lung), pericardial mesothelioma (the heart area) and peritoneal mesothelioma, which affects the stomach area.
Pleural mesothelioma is both the most common form of the disease, though all forms have a tendency to remain dormant for decades until the symptoms become so severe patients seek medical advice. Unfortunately, by that time the tumor has usually invaded so much vital tissue that no cure is possible, and most patients at this advanced stage are given about a year, or slightly more, to live.
Schroon Lake Central School serves about 275 students from kindergarten to 12th grade, with a surprisingly comprehensive academic program that can provide up to 22 transferable college credits. The school was recognized in 2008 by U.S. News and World Report as one of America’s “outstanding schools”.
It appears to be equally as impressive in its understanding of, and compliance with, the EPA’s Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act, or AHERA, which governs how schools across the nation identify and deal with asbestos. Workers who discovered the asbestos Monday immediately sealed off the area to prevent any potential fibers from becoming airborne and threatening the future health of students.
In addition, school officials have already scheduled air quality testing subsequent to the asbestos removal, which allows the school to have air quality reports back before the school is reopened as planned. If the reports are negative, the school will remain closed until the situation is rectified, according to Superintendent Mike Bonnewell.
The school is currently vested in a $14.7-million dual-purpose renovation, to upgrade the actual school building and to convert the former gymnasium into an auditorium. Most of the work so far has taken place on the exterior, but the removal of an interior wall revealed asbestos. The work is expected to be finished by the fall of 2010. Both phases are the result of a voter-approved bond measure in 2006 which allocated about $14.7 million for school upgrades and improvements.
The unscheduled closure will count as one of the district’s five allocated snow-emergency days, which are regulated by the New York State Legislature.
Officials at Schroon Lake Central School hope to bring the students back on Thursday. In the interim, The Essex County Health Department is standing by to make sure asbestos remediation in performed in accordance with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations, as well as the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) mandates.
The school, built in 1936 when former President Franklin D. Roosevelt instituted the Works Progress Administration (WPA) to support a flagging economy, is certainly old enough to contain asbestos, which was widely used in various construction materials like insulation, floor and ceiling tiles, sealants and mastics during most of the last century.
In 1989, when health officials began to recognize its dangers, the EPA limited the use of asbestos in domestic products to one percent or less by weight (or volume), thus greatly curtailing the legacy costs of asbestos illnesses, which are estimated by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) to total about $120 to $150 billion between 2005 and 2055.
Asbestos is comprised of long, very fine fibers which can, when inhaled or ingested, lead to a number of debilitating and potentially fatal diseases. The first of these is asbestosis, which is usually acquired through long exposure to asbestos. The other is mesothelioma, a cancer of the mesothelial lining inside the body that occurs as pleural mesothelioma (the lung), pericardial mesothelioma (the heart area) and peritoneal mesothelioma, which affects the stomach area.
Pleural mesothelioma is both the most common form of the disease, though all forms have a tendency to remain dormant for decades until the symptoms become so severe patients seek medical advice. Unfortunately, by that time the tumor has usually invaded so much vital tissue that no cure is possible, and most patients at this advanced stage are given about a year, or slightly more, to live.
Schroon Lake Central School serves about 275 students from kindergarten to 12th grade, with a surprisingly comprehensive academic program that can provide up to 22 transferable college credits. The school was recognized in 2008 by U.S. News and World Report as one of America’s “outstanding schools”.
It appears to be equally as impressive in its understanding of, and compliance with, the EPA’s Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act, or AHERA, which governs how schools across the nation identify and deal with asbestos. Workers who discovered the asbestos Monday immediately sealed off the area to prevent any potential fibers from becoming airborne and threatening the future health of students.
In addition, school officials have already scheduled air quality testing subsequent to the asbestos removal, which allows the school to have air quality reports back before the school is reopened as planned. If the reports are negative, the school will remain closed until the situation is rectified, according to Superintendent Mike Bonnewell.
The school is currently vested in a $14.7-million dual-purpose renovation, to upgrade the actual school building and to convert the former gymnasium into an auditorium. Most of the work so far has taken place on the exterior, but the removal of an interior wall revealed asbestos. The work is expected to be finished by the fall of 2010. Both phases are the result of a voter-approved bond measure in 2006 which allocated about $14.7 million for school upgrades and improvements.
The unscheduled closure will count as one of the district’s five allocated snow-emergency days, which are regulated by the New York State Legislature.
Indiana Mesothelioma Sufferers Seek Expanded Rights
Seventy-six year old Dorothy Kuykendall told a committee of the Indiana state legislature about how she had contracted mesothelioma by working in a local Glas-Col Apparatus Company where she had been exposed to toxic asbestos fibers. Mrs. Kuykendall testified before the committee in order to alter a state law that limits the amount of time that asbestos workers have to file claims against the companies responsible for the conditions under which they were exposed to asbestos.
Mrs. Kuykendall is part of a group that is challenging an Indiana Supreme Court ruling that limits the liability period for such firms to ten years. They say that the ruling does not take into account the fact that diseases such as mesothelioma, asbestosis and other forms of lung cancer may not become apparent until several decades after exposure.
Mrs. Kuykendall and others who have testified stated that the limited time span allows companies to evade responsibility for exposing workers to dangerous substances such as asbestos. The group wants to change the law so that patients with such diseases can file legal actions up to two years after they receive their diagnoses. According to their testimony, Indiana is the only state in the Union that does not allow for such exemptions when it comes to diseases that do not appear within a few months or years after exposure.
Mesothelioma, a disease that both Mrs. Kuykendall and her husband suffer from, is an aggressive form of cancer that affects the fluid lining of the lungs. Dr. David Mares, a physician who specializes in respiratory and pulmonary disorders, stated that mesothelioma is almost always associated with asbestos exposure. He also said that symptoms may not occur for as much as sixty years after exposure and that patients with the disease often live less than two years after their initial diagnosis.
Mrs. Kuykendall stated that she worked at the Glas-Col Apparatus Company, a factory in her hometown of Terre Haute, Indiana, for several years. She stopped handling asbestos-laced materials as part of her job in 1975. However, she received a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma from her doctor last April. She also testified that her husband, thirteen years her senior, also contracted the disease as he worked at various construction sites in the 1960s and 1970s.
US Centers for Disease Control statistics told of up to seventy Indiana residents a year die from mesothelioma. Although the state legislature had previously carved out an exemption in 1989, a 2003 ruling from the state Supreme Court effectively neutralized the clause.
State legislators are confident that the exemption will pass when it comes up for a vote in the General Assembly sometime early next year. One lawmaker, Republican State Senator John Waterman, told a story of how he worked for a demolition firm in the 1960s. During his time on the job, he recalled being surrounded by a white cloud of asbestos and having the toxic fibers blanketing his work truck. He mentioned how many of his former co-workers at the site had died of lung cancer and other diseases and that he would lead the charge for the exemption when the Assembly reconvenes.
Mrs. Kuykendall is part of a group that is challenging an Indiana Supreme Court ruling that limits the liability period for such firms to ten years. They say that the ruling does not take into account the fact that diseases such as mesothelioma, asbestosis and other forms of lung cancer may not become apparent until several decades after exposure.
Mrs. Kuykendall and others who have testified stated that the limited time span allows companies to evade responsibility for exposing workers to dangerous substances such as asbestos. The group wants to change the law so that patients with such diseases can file legal actions up to two years after they receive their diagnoses. According to their testimony, Indiana is the only state in the Union that does not allow for such exemptions when it comes to diseases that do not appear within a few months or years after exposure.
Mesothelioma, a disease that both Mrs. Kuykendall and her husband suffer from, is an aggressive form of cancer that affects the fluid lining of the lungs. Dr. David Mares, a physician who specializes in respiratory and pulmonary disorders, stated that mesothelioma is almost always associated with asbestos exposure. He also said that symptoms may not occur for as much as sixty years after exposure and that patients with the disease often live less than two years after their initial diagnosis.
Mrs. Kuykendall stated that she worked at the Glas-Col Apparatus Company, a factory in her hometown of Terre Haute, Indiana, for several years. She stopped handling asbestos-laced materials as part of her job in 1975. However, she received a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma from her doctor last April. She also testified that her husband, thirteen years her senior, also contracted the disease as he worked at various construction sites in the 1960s and 1970s.
US Centers for Disease Control statistics told of up to seventy Indiana residents a year die from mesothelioma. Although the state legislature had previously carved out an exemption in 1989, a 2003 ruling from the state Supreme Court effectively neutralized the clause.
State legislators are confident that the exemption will pass when it comes up for a vote in the General Assembly sometime early next year. One lawmaker, Republican State Senator John Waterman, told a story of how he worked for a demolition firm in the 1960s. During his time on the job, he recalled being surrounded by a white cloud of asbestos and having the toxic fibers blanketing his work truck. He mentioned how many of his former co-workers at the site had died of lung cancer and other diseases and that he would lead the charge for the exemption when the Assembly reconvenes.
Mesothelioma News: Asbestos Removal Underway at Upstate New York High School
Ongoing construction efforts at John C. Birdlebough High School in Phoenix, New York, have uncovered asbestos insulation around the water pipes as well as in some of the floor and ceiling tiles. Scott Bulriss, a contractor with the company who is working on the building, stated that asbestos is commonly found in many structures built from the early 1900s up until 1990. The main building for Birdlebough High was constructed during the 1950s. Mr. Bulriss also mentioned that some asbestos was found at nearby Dillon Middle School, but will be removed from the buildings before classes resume for the fall semester.
Mr. Bulriss explained that construction firms and contractors take all the necessary precautions to remove asbestos before the potentially hazardous material could be exposed to schoolchildren. Although he stressed that short-term exposure is not necessarily harmful, he also said that, when workers run across a substance that could be asbestos, work on any project stops for several days or weeks while the material is sent away for testing.
Chuck Morse, who works with Mr. Bulriss at Campus CMG, stated that, in the event that workers do encounter such a substance, the company also tests the indoor air quality for potential contamination. Workers will also often construct an airtight seal around the area to insure that the possible contamination does not spread to other parts of the structure. From there, the company will call another firm that specializes in asbestos abatement and remediation to handle the safe removal of the substance from the building.
Mr. Morse said that the asbestos abatement process Birdlebough High had halted the other required construction work on the school for nearly two weeks. He stated that the abatement workers made sure that all of the asbestos had been removed from the building and that none of the harmful fibers had been released into the school's air circulation and ventilation systems and assured students, faculty and workers that the school was now safe.
The asbestos abatement was part of a $41 million project that included putting in new seats at the high school's auditorium, upgrading the school's media center and adding new school security devices. The project also covered renovating and adding a new two-story structure to Dillon Middle School as well as updating computer networks and fixing the heating and wiring systems at nearby Maroun Elementary. While the asbestos removal was a major project at Birdlebough High and some asbestos was found at Dillon Middle School, no reports of asbestos contamination were released in relation to Maroun Elementary.
One parent still expressed his concern over the general safety of the school environment during the construction. Dave Rodman, who has a daughter attending Birdlebough High, was worried about the amount of dust, dirt and other airborne contaminants left over from the construction efforts. Phoenix Schools Superintendent Rita Racette released a statement reiterating the fact that most portions of the school were ready for classes and that work on all the facilities in the district was progressing on schedule. She also stated that areas of the campus that are still undergoing renovation will be sealed off and that the school has relocated those functions, such as the media center, to areas that are still accessible to all students.
Mr. Bulriss explained that construction firms and contractors take all the necessary precautions to remove asbestos before the potentially hazardous material could be exposed to schoolchildren. Although he stressed that short-term exposure is not necessarily harmful, he also said that, when workers run across a substance that could be asbestos, work on any project stops for several days or weeks while the material is sent away for testing.
Chuck Morse, who works with Mr. Bulriss at Campus CMG, stated that, in the event that workers do encounter such a substance, the company also tests the indoor air quality for potential contamination. Workers will also often construct an airtight seal around the area to insure that the possible contamination does not spread to other parts of the structure. From there, the company will call another firm that specializes in asbestos abatement and remediation to handle the safe removal of the substance from the building.
Mr. Morse said that the asbestos abatement process Birdlebough High had halted the other required construction work on the school for nearly two weeks. He stated that the abatement workers made sure that all of the asbestos had been removed from the building and that none of the harmful fibers had been released into the school's air circulation and ventilation systems and assured students, faculty and workers that the school was now safe.
The asbestos abatement was part of a $41 million project that included putting in new seats at the high school's auditorium, upgrading the school's media center and adding new school security devices. The project also covered renovating and adding a new two-story structure to Dillon Middle School as well as updating computer networks and fixing the heating and wiring systems at nearby Maroun Elementary. While the asbestos removal was a major project at Birdlebough High and some asbestos was found at Dillon Middle School, no reports of asbestos contamination were released in relation to Maroun Elementary.
One parent still expressed his concern over the general safety of the school environment during the construction. Dave Rodman, who has a daughter attending Birdlebough High, was worried about the amount of dust, dirt and other airborne contaminants left over from the construction efforts. Phoenix Schools Superintendent Rita Racette released a statement reiterating the fact that most portions of the school were ready for classes and that work on all the facilities in the district was progressing on schedule. She also stated that areas of the campus that are still undergoing renovation will be sealed off and that the school has relocated those functions, such as the media center, to areas that are still accessible to all students.
New Jersey Contractor Cited for Asbestos Violations
A construction crew working on asbestos-based sealing panels on the roof of a high school in Long Island, New York, lifted a cloud of white debris when workers neglected to damp down, and contain the potentially unsafe fibers so as to preclude them from becoming airborne, according to a report from a state worker safety inspector.
The New York State Department of Labor has issued five worker safety citations to a contracting firm based in New Jersey for failing to follow proper asbestos removal procedures as a function of a refurbishment job on the school building at Roosevelt High School. Thus far, the project has generated complaints from faculty and students of a downpour of harmful debris, which the school district claimed was Styrofoam being taken out of the roof sections.
The safety inspector issued the citations just days before the start of the academic year when he observed a "plume of white dust" emerging from the top of the building. The inspector also noted that at least three workers on the roof did not have the respirators and breathing filters that the state requires they wear during asbestos removal projects.
Karen Williamson, a spokesperson for the Department of Labor, said that another inspector visited the school last week. The second visit was a result of continued complaints from teachers and other staff members at the school about the possible hazards involved in the ongoing work. Ms. Williamson acknowledged the seriousness of the infractions, which also prompted her office to start a new investigation into the problems.
David Weiser, an assistant superintendent for the school district, responded that the "white dust" the inspector saw was not a highly dangerous cloud of asbestos fibers, but Styrofoam insulation left over from a previous contractor. He also said that the district conducted quality testing on the air circulating throughout the school, which resulted in finding no traces of asbestos. Mr. Weiser also mentioned that his office sent letters to concerned parents informing them of the results and ordered work crews to clean up any debris.
Superior Abatement, Inc., based in West Caldwell, New Jersey, carried out the asbestos removal portion of the project to renovate the fifty-four-year-old structure. The company started the project on September 3 and finished three weeks later. When the company's owner, Nicholas Petrovski, found out about the citations for safety infractions the day after work on the project started, he dismissed the crew who had worked on the roof during the inspection and hired a new crew a few days later.
The day that Mr. Petrovski hired the new asbestos abatement crew was also the day that classes at Roosevelt resumed for the new school year. School district officials and Mr. Petrovski both agreed that asbestos disposal work would only occur after the end of the school day in order to minimize the impact on students and teachers.
In a related incident, officials at a nearby elementary school admitted that they failed to check the credentials of another contracting firm that had been hired to remove asbestos. New York state law requires that asbestos cleanup firms carry a license from the state labor department; the firm hired to clean out asbestos-laced crawl spaces under the Rushmore Elementary School did not have such a license. Superintendent Michael Mahoney admitted to the error and sent letters to parents telling them that no asbestos contamination had been found in the school's airways or ventilation systems.
The New York State Department of Labor has issued five worker safety citations to a contracting firm based in New Jersey for failing to follow proper asbestos removal procedures as a function of a refurbishment job on the school building at Roosevelt High School. Thus far, the project has generated complaints from faculty and students of a downpour of harmful debris, which the school district claimed was Styrofoam being taken out of the roof sections.
The safety inspector issued the citations just days before the start of the academic year when he observed a "plume of white dust" emerging from the top of the building. The inspector also noted that at least three workers on the roof did not have the respirators and breathing filters that the state requires they wear during asbestos removal projects.
Karen Williamson, a spokesperson for the Department of Labor, said that another inspector visited the school last week. The second visit was a result of continued complaints from teachers and other staff members at the school about the possible hazards involved in the ongoing work. Ms. Williamson acknowledged the seriousness of the infractions, which also prompted her office to start a new investigation into the problems.
David Weiser, an assistant superintendent for the school district, responded that the "white dust" the inspector saw was not a highly dangerous cloud of asbestos fibers, but Styrofoam insulation left over from a previous contractor. He also said that the district conducted quality testing on the air circulating throughout the school, which resulted in finding no traces of asbestos. Mr. Weiser also mentioned that his office sent letters to concerned parents informing them of the results and ordered work crews to clean up any debris.
Superior Abatement, Inc., based in West Caldwell, New Jersey, carried out the asbestos removal portion of the project to renovate the fifty-four-year-old structure. The company started the project on September 3 and finished three weeks later. When the company's owner, Nicholas Petrovski, found out about the citations for safety infractions the day after work on the project started, he dismissed the crew who had worked on the roof during the inspection and hired a new crew a few days later.
The day that Mr. Petrovski hired the new asbestos abatement crew was also the day that classes at Roosevelt resumed for the new school year. School district officials and Mr. Petrovski both agreed that asbestos disposal work would only occur after the end of the school day in order to minimize the impact on students and teachers.
In a related incident, officials at a nearby elementary school admitted that they failed to check the credentials of another contracting firm that had been hired to remove asbestos. New York state law requires that asbestos cleanup firms carry a license from the state labor department; the firm hired to clean out asbestos-laced crawl spaces under the Rushmore Elementary School did not have such a license. Superintendent Michael Mahoney admitted to the error and sent letters to parents telling them that no asbestos contamination had been found in the school's airways or ventilation systems.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)